Eddie's Sweet Shop
Lots of reviewers have described Eddie's as a place out of time: much of the interior looks the way a 19th century ice cream parlor should: but the old-fashioned features extend to the shop entrance, which has a shallow step and therefore is NOT wheelchair friendly. The counterman, nearly as ancient as the shop, claimed that all the whipped cream and toppings are homemade as well as the ice cream. I tried a dish of the pistachio-pineapple ice cream: the pineapple was dyed green, possibly candied, and in very small wisps of flavor. I was glad that they included a metal saucer under the long-stemmed cup, because the homemade chocolate sauce is more watery than the mass-produced version. The dish of ice cream with whipped cream and chocolate sauce cost $4.00. The Banana Split is $6.50 and the Banana Royale is $1.00 more. Eddie's is an interminable bus ride from the nearest subway station.

printPrint rateRate reportReport
post reply

Comments on Eddie's Sweet Shop


Posted 06/02/07:
quote post
smiling face

I would walk to Eddie's with my father when I was a small girl. I still try to make time to go for a special treat. Its a classic great place and a wonderful experience. Plus great ice cream sundaes!
Search thread for
Download thread as
post reply

Quick Reply
Your Name:
Your Comment:

smiling face wink grin cool nod sticking out tongue raised eyebrow confused shocked shaking head disapproval rolling eyes sad mad

Click a smilie to insert it into your message. You may use WSN Codes in your message.
Anti-Spam Image:
Type the letters and numbers shown on the left into the box on the right (this is to prevent automated submissions).